Using fresh ideas and quality service to deliver peace of mind to businesses, families, and individuals all over Ohio


We love small businesses! Whether you have a brick and mortar store, manufacturing facilty, office environment, or are a contractor working around Ohio, we have a great policy for you.


Personal or Commercial Auto, we can write a single vehicle, household with 5 cars, or an entire commercial fleet.

Home & Renters

Protect your largest asset with the proper coverage, or cover your personal belongings with an inexpensive renters policy.


With over 50 life carriers, let us find the right policy at a great company for you and your family.

What Our Customers Are Saying

Don’t just take it from us, let our clients do the talking!

“DJ was extremely efficient and clear while explaining my policy to me. He is always willing to do whatever it takes to make sure that everything makes sense to me before moving on and he got me a great rate.

Highly Recommend The Loy Insurance Agency!

Justin: Auto, Home, Life

“DJ is a very knowledgable personable agent. I could not be happier with his attention to detail, his desire to do things based on my personal needs and his willingness to go above and beyond to get the job done..

I HIGHLY recommend DJ and Loy Insurance to anyone looking for top notch care with impeccable service.”

Steve: Home, Auto, Life

“DJ was extremely helpful with my contractors insurance needs. He has gone above and beyond… very reliable insurance agent.


I have worked with others and DJ makes life much simpler.”

Cory: Business, Auto

We are an independent insurance agency offering a comprehensive suite of insurance solutions to protect your business and your life from the unexpected.

We offer business, life, home and auto insurance coverage for residents and businesses across Ohio.

We do more than sell insurance. We work closely with clients to help them make important and informed decisions every day when it comes to their protection and future.

Don't Be Shy

If we didn't answer all of your questions, feel free to drop us a line anytime.


6338 Hibiscus Ct
Westerville, Oh 43081